On Papal Supremacy and Infallibility

This entry is part 3 of 6 in the series Catholic or Protestant?

According to the Catholic Church, the pope, the bishop of Rome, is the supreme head of the entire Church, having authority over every bishop and every Christian.  Further, in 1870, the First Vatican Council of the Roman Catholic Church officially declared the dogma of papal infallibility: when the pope speaks ex cathedra (officially as the … Read more

Is Apostolic Succession Necessary?

This entry is part 2 of 6 in the series Catholic or Protestant?

What is the Church?  This is one of the biggest issues dividing the Protestant and Catholic traditions.  According to the Protestant tradition, the Church exists wherever a disciplined community of Jesus’s disciples gathers around the preaching of God’s word and the administration of the sacraments (baptism and the Lord’s Supper).  According to the Catholic tradition, … Read more

Why the Apocrypha is Not Scripture

This entry is part 1 of 6 in the series Catholic or Protestant?

In this series, I will explore some of the key differences between the Protestant and Catholic traditions and explain why, in most of these cases, I believe the Protestant position to be correct.  In a previous post, I have already made the case for why the Protestant idea that Scripture alone is our highest Authority … Read more

The Significance of the Book of Revelation

Apocalyptic Genre Two books of the Bible are of the literary genre known as apocalyptic literature.  In the Old Testament, there is the book of Daniel.  In the New Testament, there is the book of Revelation.  Of the various literary genres found in Scripture, apocalyptic is one of the least well understood and most frequently … Read more

Should Christians Pray All the Psalms Today?

The Psalms occupy a unique place in the canon of Scripture.  Most of the writings that make up the Scriptures consist of God’s prophetic words to us, or narratives about God’s dealings with human beings in salvation history.  The book of Psalms, on the other hand, is a collection of human prayers addressed to God.  … Read more

The Enduring Moral Authority of the Torah for Christians Today

Theonomy or Dismissal? What does the Old Testament Law have to tell Christians about how they should live today?  Christians have given a wide variety of answers to this question.   On one end of the spectrum there are theonomists, who believe that the Old Testament Law should be the model for the laws of civil … Read more

Top Ten Quotes on Christian Nonviolence

The Gospel and Nonviolence “When people with power see things happen of which they disapprove, they drop bombs and send in tanks.  When people without power see things of which they disapprove, they smash store windows, blow themselves up in crowded places, and fly planes into buildings.  The fact that both methods have proved remarkably … Read more

Where Should the Church Go From Here?

This entry is part 4 of 4 in the series Church, Government, and Society

The past 2,000 years of Church history have been a long and winding road.  The early Church tried to do its best to live out the radically countercultural reality of Jesus’s Kingdom in the midst of a hostile culture.  But beginning in the fourth century, there was a dramatic transition to Christendom, in which Christianity … Read more

From Christendom to the Modern Church

This entry is part 3 of 4 in the series Church, Government, and Society

The End of Christendom For many centuries, from the late Roman Empire, through the Middle Ages, and into the Modern period, the political, social, and ecclesial status quo in Western civilization was that of Christendom.  All of society was (supposedly) Christian.  “Christian” governments used coercion and violence to force everyone to be part of the … Read more

From the Early Church to Christendom

This entry is part 2 of 4 in the series Church, Government, and Society

A Great Apostasy? There is a popular belief among many Christians that in the early fourth century, with the conversion of the Roman Emperor Constantine to Christianity, the church suddenly committed a “Great Apostasy” by turning away from the Way of Jesus, making a grab for worldly political power, and embracing “Constantinianism.”  Usually this is … Read more